Alfred Thelen,
Markus Tilsch,
Alexander V. Tikhonravov,
Michael K. Trubetskov,
and Ulf Brauneck
A. Thelen’s (athelen@t-online.de) address is Rosskopfstrasse 13, 60439 Frankfurt/Main, Germany.
M. Tilsch (markus_tilsch@ocli.com) is with JDS Uniphase, Santa Rosa, California 95407. USA
A. V. Tikhonravov (tikh@tikh.srcc.msu.su) and M. K. Trubetskov (miket@trub.srcc.msu.su) are with the Research Computing Center, Moscow State University, 119899, Moscow, Russia.
U. Braunek (buc@schott.de) is with Schott Glaswerke, 55122 Mainz, Germany.
Alfred Thelen, Markus Tilsch, Alexander V. Tikhonravov, Michael K. Trubetskov, and Ulf Brauneck, "Topical Meeting on Optical interference Coatings (OIC’2001): design contest results," Appl. Opt. 41, 3022-3038 (2002)
A gain-flattening filter (GFF) for minimum manufacturing errors (12 designs submitted) and dense wavelength-division multiplex (DWDM) filters for low group-delay (GD) variation (9 designs submitted) was the subject of a design contest held in conjunction with the Optical Interference Coatings 2001 topical meeting of the Optical Society of America. Results of the contest are given and evaluated. It turned out that the parameter space for GFFs with optimum performance when manufacturing errors are not considered is much different from that when manufacturing errors are considered. DWDM filter solutions with low GD variation are possible.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Cited by links are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Figure files are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Article tables are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Equations are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
No contest means that the design was ineligible to be named a winner.
Table 4
GFF Designs Ranked According to Merit Function and Maximum Width Error Corridor (dB), Assuming Zero Errors
Design
Merit Function (dB)
Thelen2
0.513
Thelen1
0.544
Tikhon1
0.762
Dahan
0.83
Tikhon2
0.992
Thome
1.01
Verly
1.13
Placido2
1.24
Southw1
1.32
Placido1
1.34
Southw2
1.35
Noe
1.52
Error Corridor Width (db)
Thelen1
0.15
Thelen2
0.15
Dahan
0.24
Placido1
0.29
Southw1
0.29
Southw2
0.31
Thome
0.31
Verly
0.31
Tikhon1
0.32
Noe
0.33
Tikhon2
0.33
Placido2
0.36
Table 5
GFF Performance with Both Errors Doubled (εabs = ±0.06 nm εrel = ±0.03%)
Design
Yield
Verly
37
Placido2
26
Placido1
13
Tikhon1
13
Noe
12
Tikhon2
9
Thome
4
Dahan
1
Southw1
1
Southw2
0
Thelen1
0
Thelen2
0
Table 6
GFF Performance with Absolute Errors Only (εabs = ±0.2nm εrel = ±0%)
Design
Yield
Thome
89
Dahan
61
Verly
51
Placido2
32
Tikhon1
23
Placido1
18
Tikhon2
18
Southw2
4
Noe
4
Thelen1
0
Thelen2
0
Southw1
0
Table 7
GFF Performance with Relative Errors Only (εabs = ±0 nm εrel = ±0.03%)
Design
Yield
Verly
74
Placido2
54
Noe
51
Placido1
44
Tikhon2
42
Tikhon1
36
Southw1
6
Southw2
5
Thome
4
Dahan
3
Thelen1
1
Thelen2
0
Table 8
Total Physical Thicknesses TpTh and Total Optical Thicknesses ToTh of All Layers, Total Optical Thicknesses of all High-Index Layers H and All Low-Index Layers L, and Their Ratio
Design
TpTh (µm)
ToTh (µm)
ToTh H (µm)
ToTh L (µm)
Ratio H/L
Verly
87.3
151.5
81.4
70.1
1.2
Tikhon1
98.0
172.2
104.3
67.9
1.5
Tikhon2
96.9
166.2
99.4
66.7
1.5
Placido2
99.9
177.0
105.2
71.8
1.5
Placido1
98.7
175.7
106.9
68.7
1.6
Noe
55.4
98.7
60.3
38.4
1.6
Dahan
95.1
163.0
81.4
81.5
1.0
Thome
93.7
173.6
99.5
74.1
1.3
Southw1
47.1
84.6
53.3
31.4
1.7
Southw2
56.0
111.4
100.8
10.6
9.5
Thelen1
49.8
90.6
60.8
29.8
2.0
Thelen2
49.8
90.6
60.9
29.8
2.0
Table 9
QWOT of Seven Selected Designs at the Design Wavelength of 1550 nm
a
Layer Number
Design
Verly
Tikhon1
Noe
Thome
Dahan
Thelen2
Thelen1
1
5.4598446
1.43357189
1.009809
0.997585
8.31755355
2.861179
2.655175
2
2.8778412
0.60248917
1.015042
4.98757
4.88141781
0.941599
0.923162
3
3.0760231
1.17395061
1.009523
8.206986
6.83538981
0.93157
0.989613
4
2.0049782
1.54687773
0.979341
8.698025
4.46959213
2.847506
2.835669
5
2.048996
0.8611978
1.555818
8.975401
6.95955626
0.925755
0.940082
6
2.0417483
1.74447149
1.633832
6.985156
6.73283755
2.509764
2.549144
7
1.9532987
3.22436453
0.95243
13.01302
2.83994787
0.649683
0.656999
8
2.1590815
2.74277655
0.979659
7.760605
0.76716852
1.005589
0.997697
9
2.8114209
3.23023833
0.968552
11.121246
6.98092568
0.911768
0.861465
10
2.7444406
2.52051063
0.970553
8.990346
8.6839529
0.941359
0.897272
11
6.1037693
2.91929584
4.933054
8.980766
6.58359303
0.912922
0.854817
12
0.0378065
3.26048607
0.983622
8.974444
8.83778735
0.968618
0.999522
13
8.8294964
1.28357897
0.995222
12.618559
4.84046658
0.953769
0.98297
14
2.8756213
3.08497318
0.973681
6.289419
1.02236206
0.973777
0.997129
15
3.0365505
3.08063241
0.574373
10.958633
2.84170645
0.942815
0.969622
16
2.3676362
1.39797499
0.398426
6.983655
6.82705123
0.962337
0.944322
17
1.5103165
3.25494541
2.886859
12.984134
2.88364594
0.959228
0.968342
18
2.0813007
1.25105213
2.928137
7.008051
2.58184039
0.949483
0.932584
19
1.839977
2.69671373
6.409002
11.404743
2.72366839
0.766914
0.757732
20
1.9469955
1.16884881
1.016845
9.441503
4.87548219
0.419781
0.422566
21
2.9828262
3.16113512
1.058635
11.020227
2.93411187
0.751039
0.761545
22
3.4734163
3.18045514
2.103677
8.983696
10.8506407
1.136631
1.154125
23
3.860508
1.19183334
1.128024
8.968155
2.88748284
4.79261
4.763438
24
2.5735581
3.1653562
2.531032
4.968955
2.9211911
1.035119
1.065466
25
0.0532903
2.69127481
1.077512
10.228781
8.87550323
1.018001
1.029262
26
2.3682873
1.89153399
0.696423
6.810495
14.3261121
0.986963
0.980274
27
3.792994
3.06163157
5.211235
10.926745
4.89833987
0.90083
0.861334
28
3.110832
1.87370213
2.664129
8.960186
12.8433053
0.977228
0.962824
29
3.1206417
2.67981346
0.976467
10.944134
4.93180619
1.018908
0.949766
30
2.1345236
2.16797774
0.929654
8.901163
8.83143587
0.918348
0.930503
31
1.8684237
2.44887597
1.109513
8.312107
6.85990335
1.008999
1.012223
32
2.1195748
2.07715972
1.362219
6.809327
2.81737458
0.975684
1.002385
33
1.8334434
3.57007706
1.773516
12.902661
4.32792026
0.972806
0.990947
34
2.032928
2.24497253
1.058196
8.959887
4.921228
1.004811
1.071903
35
3.0514565
4.01911825
3.899304
10.949011
2.9592649
2.570515
2.512333
36
4.1227903
1.99574536
0.997436
6.865141
4.92292929
0.504434
0.511263
37
4.7508326
2.83273081
1.384364
14.061612
4.95056439
0.852864
0.855145
38
2.6459916
2.88926554
1.475041
6.975503
4.89457445
0.960081
0.958637
39
3.3007841
2.66022714
1.842347
10.96121
1.00942529
0.978251
0.962222
40
1.9936746
1.40541374
0.62462
6.969709
6.74830039
0.931834
0.966304
41
1.9362736
3.05515633
0.729393
10.598114
4.50196645
0.967911
0.950123
42
2.0804527
1.20820399
0.904236
8.30989
4.76304581
1.016449
0.987372
43
1.944476
2.24139579
2.918778
12.938951
4.90052477
0.954546
0.936668
44
2.025322
1.52265739
0.972008
4.977255
2.96595394
0.98455
0.967319
45
2.9359908
4.10344008
5.069013
12.887482
10.9028803
2.972056
2.946015
46
2.7895172
2.98347579
0.96346
7.624398
2.98228632
1.000728
1.028328
47
5.0145836
1.4176032
2.893521
11.641718
2.94487652
4.997885
5.111613
48
4.8203235
2.87983195
0.937147
4.95185123
0.944061
0.903874
49
5.2106075
2.32202717
0.860107
2.90219097
0.974694
0.993201
50
2.9305425
2.79921254
1.745814
2.94243832
0.958942
0.945505
51
3.1424911
2.7009009
1.738444
4.28454194
2.297887
2.245077
52
2.1971028
1.36707893
1.170049
4.84516142
0.704207
0.748347
53
2.0818732
2.16127808
2.479351
4.96873639
2.937808
2.94683
54
2.1654284
2.26886771
0.264831
2.95691819
0.986753
0.972705
55
1.782299
2.58382481
2.768395
6.89869871
1.026515
1.011527
56
2.1894767
2.36693697
1.310683
2.9848497
0.896015
0.907233
57
2.7756817
3.49261149
1.467155
4.98269845
3.078305
3.098005
58
3.6374691
1.7667698
1.773218
4.91166297
1.027662
1.042171
59
0.0532903
2.09543344
0.843303
10.2855119
3.072019
3.105594
60
1.954398
1.715287
0.793207
2.73824568
0.879894
0.887063
61
1.4943676
4.01765403
0.882634
4.87766323
0.8936
0.940814
62
3.1932235
1.71114073
0.89625
4.97132155
1.146807
1.1353
63
0.0532903
4.0526445
2.866731
0.99322503
9.460221
9.479649
64
2.1963506
1.49497801
2.876233
12.8602048
1.353794
1.30921
65
2.5395713
2.56042136
0.962948
10.7058659
5.266034
5.222153
66
1.777885
2.1015945
0.95443
0.92157007
0.999773
1.024108
67
1.8750168
3.31873935
0.950515
2.71722026
3.008141
3.04124
68
1.994689
1.31469745
0.888873
6.57412607
1.003533
0.998415
69
1.8955503
2.95390729
1.708796
2.90320348
0.994754
0.992537
70
1.8414512
2.62001219
2.001997
8.88735161
0.975307
1.003249
71
3.3488586
2.67989525
0.753094
14.8743948
0.982918
0.990547
72
2.7138155
1.56776269
0.822026
6.88096323
0.988096
0.996476
73
3.8698575
3.23182922
3.501343
4.93361807
2.930031
2.962133
74
3.8470712
2.22932302
1.665641
3.02031961
0.953017
0.9606
75
2.8111708
2.11657275
2.486446
4.38248955
0.869143
0.847444
76
1.9400733
2.18113869
0.782514
2.53821174
0.678865
0.673127
77
1.6473314
1.28993452
0.205472
4.89274439
0.723819
0.711026
78
2.1050572
2.55937108
1.032065
2.96058542
2.628607
2.603131
79
1.7176747
1.93797284
2.682008
4.88571006
0.931159
0.959802
80
1.9909898
2.06656014
1.425749
0.960679
0.957032
81
3.2146502
4.65232294
0.85831
0.960257
0.987203
82
2.95907
1.90425807
1.019405
0.959185
0.973435
83
2.7428901
1.55356642
5.146495
0.970956
0.978565
84
0.0378065
1.68721962
0.946677
1.005567
0.996249
85
3.079392
3.44844975
0.895436
0.949156
0.974333
86
4.5020981
1.85254886
0.656942
1.009251
1.014985
87
3.9024432
4.04370763
0.645179
0.996625
0.995208
88
2.8997397
1.98952945
2.13414
0.999142
1.052778
89
3.3251212
3.12231457
2.304694
9.328359
9.311068
90
2.1874106
2.40483192
0.662366
2.960844
2.991622
91
1.9246382
1.74143734
0.450039
8.037046
8.044436
92
2.0318122
2.91798723
1.129225
0.446191
0.384609
93
1.7805613
3.07635647
3.425294
1.429491
1.435924
94
1.9853759
2.44727611
1.175364
0.910507
0.89959
95
2.863035
3.35159435
1.691766
3.09037
3.073034
96
3.1877799
2.52642133
2.061139
0.820848
0.836608
97
5.3795643
2.30624101
0.789433
1.033323
1.020682
98
4.55932
1.86382069
0.644554
0.99304
0.996906
99
2.6410007
2.36713247
0.585822
5.317398
5.347204
100
0.0378065
1.43475183
1.217514
0.571664
0.556586
101
3.0004001
2.16983893
3.425954
6.403354
6.391492
102
3.0257533
1.35224929
0.801975
0.593475
0.616601
103
2.8887875
2.96685978
1.808644
3.112822
3.102034
104
1.7377354
2.5587856
1.258479
0.944764
0.948817
105
2.1610322
2.35054638
1.976514
0.93368
0.932431
106
2.0731809
1.53620335
0.447329
0.943347
0.925902
107
2.0302567
1.89336426
1.0489
3.189666
3.203618
108
2.0573139
2.04989127
2.98365
0.924421
0.930771
109
2.8764
3.15940959
0.912856
0.943382
0.947306
110
2.9346962
1.97520651
0.753454
0.905848
0.895851
111
4.9592495
3.00360571
0.854643
0.937878
0.93322
112
1.9042639
1.65216033
0.905133
0.929599
0.934823
113
0.0532903
2.99472269
5.268046
0.914395
0.914716
114
2.9358604
2.9696346
1.064356
0.868175
0.865078
115
2.08796
3.522561
2.726234
2.75463
2.736351
116
0.0378065
2.17021695
1.402024
0.4497
0.458532
117
2.8200119
1.13882549
1.430055
4.88175
4.877523
118
3.1644216
1.92502833
0.08624
0.847632
0.7741
119
1.1000553
2.33552524
0.533383
3.179227
3.305891
120
0.0378065
2.16282508
0.784668
0.999635
1.002343
121
1.5648289
2.87242212
2.635344
2.986421
2.992172
122
2.0429153
2.08175483
0.756845
0.971743
0.978232
123
1.920074
3.35338172
2.119691
0.987704
0.996188
124
2.0624425
2.49877187
2.672006
0.995507
0.994374
125
1.6385622
2.44468381
1.064622
0.906496
0.920171
126
2.3516614
2.70209182
1.057349
0.953628
0.958107
127
3.023325
2.20520443
1.716475
0.917255
0.918416
128
3.0386653
1.7528927
2.093446
0.841593
0.84152
129
4.82131
0.86268695
0.62255
0.689189
0.687297
130
3.2698152
1.74258637
0.839153
0.741565
0.74184
131
0.0858922
4.14142181
0.619628
4.646821
4.640992
132
2.0613079
2.79021581
0.951964
0.967305
0.968871
133
4.5317917
3.67614862
5.745348
0.962225
0.958825
134
3.3586502
2.04823356
1.012427
0.960894
0.960314
135
3.0385163
3.39496613
0.814653
0.959172
0.958669
136
1.7362652
1.21114837
0.349122
0.961976
0.960929
137
1.8660618
4.83712281
1.36382
0.959798
0.954147
138
2.1012206
2.31272424
1.883338
0.962403
0.958655
139
1.5916468
2.2134092
1.99204
0.959899
0.950886
140
2.4082921
1.93488583
1.880721
0.960048
0.957164
141
3.00735
3.01899489
1.533148
0.94753
0.944815
142
3.0673785
1.88364441
0.989974
0.913535
0.912069
143
4.9352169
3.388834
4.223902
0.868366
0.866665
144
3.047188
1.50863368
0.557933
0.771248
0.77092
145
2.8391557
3.65383834
0.838395
0.625116
0.624953
146
2.2018168
0.93531504
1.78453
0.776709
0.782272
147
2.1111701
4.07068582
1.706629
0.882862
0.889185
148
1.9872768
0.96683748
2.323612
0.939862
0.941413
149
2.0656612
2.81627838
1.486917
0.966876
0.963163
150
1.9417109
1.74563648
1.076442
0.970821
0.977529
151
2.7912488
2.085939
5.905075
2.932218
2.938957
152
1.9324392
2.65859237
0.962279
1.013816
1.00252
153
3.85670546
0.855204
0.487223
0.458218
154
2.05006881
1.653053
155
1.85354628
1.529038
156
3.08429693
2.539171
157
4.94706635
1.473741
158
2.27534395
1.131953
159
2.09944207
0.954754
160
2.38394995
161
2.58365725
162
2.61673865
163
2.83734887
164
1.47022406
165
3.25600168
166
2.00050605
167
3.14456799
168
2.42375995
169
1.48818758
170
2.73687482
171
3.50611056
172
2.39342344
173
2.36413223
174
2.01771652
175
1.93419761
176
2.05363658
177
2.25656255
178
3.4781908
179
2.26728281
180
0.73891319
181
4.36526366
182
1.49947139
183
1.87240249
184
3.00696302
185
2.10520017
For all designs, the first layer is a high-index layer.
Table 10
Names and Addresses of Contributors of NBP Designs
Name
Address
E-Mail Address
Jennifer D. T. Kruschwitz
JK Consulting, 47 Rossiter Road, Rochester, N.Y. 14620
No contest means that the design was ineligible to be named a winner.
Table 4
GFF Designs Ranked According to Merit Function and Maximum Width Error Corridor (dB), Assuming Zero Errors
Design
Merit Function (dB)
Thelen2
0.513
Thelen1
0.544
Tikhon1
0.762
Dahan
0.83
Tikhon2
0.992
Thome
1.01
Verly
1.13
Placido2
1.24
Southw1
1.32
Placido1
1.34
Southw2
1.35
Noe
1.52
Error Corridor Width (db)
Thelen1
0.15
Thelen2
0.15
Dahan
0.24
Placido1
0.29
Southw1
0.29
Southw2
0.31
Thome
0.31
Verly
0.31
Tikhon1
0.32
Noe
0.33
Tikhon2
0.33
Placido2
0.36
Table 5
GFF Performance with Both Errors Doubled (εabs = ±0.06 nm εrel = ±0.03%)
Design
Yield
Verly
37
Placido2
26
Placido1
13
Tikhon1
13
Noe
12
Tikhon2
9
Thome
4
Dahan
1
Southw1
1
Southw2
0
Thelen1
0
Thelen2
0
Table 6
GFF Performance with Absolute Errors Only (εabs = ±0.2nm εrel = ±0%)
Design
Yield
Thome
89
Dahan
61
Verly
51
Placido2
32
Tikhon1
23
Placido1
18
Tikhon2
18
Southw2
4
Noe
4
Thelen1
0
Thelen2
0
Southw1
0
Table 7
GFF Performance with Relative Errors Only (εabs = ±0 nm εrel = ±0.03%)
Design
Yield
Verly
74
Placido2
54
Noe
51
Placido1
44
Tikhon2
42
Tikhon1
36
Southw1
6
Southw2
5
Thome
4
Dahan
3
Thelen1
1
Thelen2
0
Table 8
Total Physical Thicknesses TpTh and Total Optical Thicknesses ToTh of All Layers, Total Optical Thicknesses of all High-Index Layers H and All Low-Index Layers L, and Their Ratio
Design
TpTh (µm)
ToTh (µm)
ToTh H (µm)
ToTh L (µm)
Ratio H/L
Verly
87.3
151.5
81.4
70.1
1.2
Tikhon1
98.0
172.2
104.3
67.9
1.5
Tikhon2
96.9
166.2
99.4
66.7
1.5
Placido2
99.9
177.0
105.2
71.8
1.5
Placido1
98.7
175.7
106.9
68.7
1.6
Noe
55.4
98.7
60.3
38.4
1.6
Dahan
95.1
163.0
81.4
81.5
1.0
Thome
93.7
173.6
99.5
74.1
1.3
Southw1
47.1
84.6
53.3
31.4
1.7
Southw2
56.0
111.4
100.8
10.6
9.5
Thelen1
49.8
90.6
60.8
29.8
2.0
Thelen2
49.8
90.6
60.9
29.8
2.0
Table 9
QWOT of Seven Selected Designs at the Design Wavelength of 1550 nm
a
Layer Number
Design
Verly
Tikhon1
Noe
Thome
Dahan
Thelen2
Thelen1
1
5.4598446
1.43357189
1.009809
0.997585
8.31755355
2.861179
2.655175
2
2.8778412
0.60248917
1.015042
4.98757
4.88141781
0.941599
0.923162
3
3.0760231
1.17395061
1.009523
8.206986
6.83538981
0.93157
0.989613
4
2.0049782
1.54687773
0.979341
8.698025
4.46959213
2.847506
2.835669
5
2.048996
0.8611978
1.555818
8.975401
6.95955626
0.925755
0.940082
6
2.0417483
1.74447149
1.633832
6.985156
6.73283755
2.509764
2.549144
7
1.9532987
3.22436453
0.95243
13.01302
2.83994787
0.649683
0.656999
8
2.1590815
2.74277655
0.979659
7.760605
0.76716852
1.005589
0.997697
9
2.8114209
3.23023833
0.968552
11.121246
6.98092568
0.911768
0.861465
10
2.7444406
2.52051063
0.970553
8.990346
8.6839529
0.941359
0.897272
11
6.1037693
2.91929584
4.933054
8.980766
6.58359303
0.912922
0.854817
12
0.0378065
3.26048607
0.983622
8.974444
8.83778735
0.968618
0.999522
13
8.8294964
1.28357897
0.995222
12.618559
4.84046658
0.953769
0.98297
14
2.8756213
3.08497318
0.973681
6.289419
1.02236206
0.973777
0.997129
15
3.0365505
3.08063241
0.574373
10.958633
2.84170645
0.942815
0.969622
16
2.3676362
1.39797499
0.398426
6.983655
6.82705123
0.962337
0.944322
17
1.5103165
3.25494541
2.886859
12.984134
2.88364594
0.959228
0.968342
18
2.0813007
1.25105213
2.928137
7.008051
2.58184039
0.949483
0.932584
19
1.839977
2.69671373
6.409002
11.404743
2.72366839
0.766914
0.757732
20
1.9469955
1.16884881
1.016845
9.441503
4.87548219
0.419781
0.422566
21
2.9828262
3.16113512
1.058635
11.020227
2.93411187
0.751039
0.761545
22
3.4734163
3.18045514
2.103677
8.983696
10.8506407
1.136631
1.154125
23
3.860508
1.19183334
1.128024
8.968155
2.88748284
4.79261
4.763438
24
2.5735581
3.1653562
2.531032
4.968955
2.9211911
1.035119
1.065466
25
0.0532903
2.69127481
1.077512
10.228781
8.87550323
1.018001
1.029262
26
2.3682873
1.89153399
0.696423
6.810495
14.3261121
0.986963
0.980274
27
3.792994
3.06163157
5.211235
10.926745
4.89833987
0.90083
0.861334
28
3.110832
1.87370213
2.664129
8.960186
12.8433053
0.977228
0.962824
29
3.1206417
2.67981346
0.976467
10.944134
4.93180619
1.018908
0.949766
30
2.1345236
2.16797774
0.929654
8.901163
8.83143587
0.918348
0.930503
31
1.8684237
2.44887597
1.109513
8.312107
6.85990335
1.008999
1.012223
32
2.1195748
2.07715972
1.362219
6.809327
2.81737458
0.975684
1.002385
33
1.8334434
3.57007706
1.773516
12.902661
4.32792026
0.972806
0.990947
34
2.032928
2.24497253
1.058196
8.959887
4.921228
1.004811
1.071903
35
3.0514565
4.01911825
3.899304
10.949011
2.9592649
2.570515
2.512333
36
4.1227903
1.99574536
0.997436
6.865141
4.92292929
0.504434
0.511263
37
4.7508326
2.83273081
1.384364
14.061612
4.95056439
0.852864
0.855145
38
2.6459916
2.88926554
1.475041
6.975503
4.89457445
0.960081
0.958637
39
3.3007841
2.66022714
1.842347
10.96121
1.00942529
0.978251
0.962222
40
1.9936746
1.40541374
0.62462
6.969709
6.74830039
0.931834
0.966304
41
1.9362736
3.05515633
0.729393
10.598114
4.50196645
0.967911
0.950123
42
2.0804527
1.20820399
0.904236
8.30989
4.76304581
1.016449
0.987372
43
1.944476
2.24139579
2.918778
12.938951
4.90052477
0.954546
0.936668
44
2.025322
1.52265739
0.972008
4.977255
2.96595394
0.98455
0.967319
45
2.9359908
4.10344008
5.069013
12.887482
10.9028803
2.972056
2.946015
46
2.7895172
2.98347579
0.96346
7.624398
2.98228632
1.000728
1.028328
47
5.0145836
1.4176032
2.893521
11.641718
2.94487652
4.997885
5.111613
48
4.8203235
2.87983195
0.937147
4.95185123
0.944061
0.903874
49
5.2106075
2.32202717
0.860107
2.90219097
0.974694
0.993201
50
2.9305425
2.79921254
1.745814
2.94243832
0.958942
0.945505
51
3.1424911
2.7009009
1.738444
4.28454194
2.297887
2.245077
52
2.1971028
1.36707893
1.170049
4.84516142
0.704207
0.748347
53
2.0818732
2.16127808
2.479351
4.96873639
2.937808
2.94683
54
2.1654284
2.26886771
0.264831
2.95691819
0.986753
0.972705
55
1.782299
2.58382481
2.768395
6.89869871
1.026515
1.011527
56
2.1894767
2.36693697
1.310683
2.9848497
0.896015
0.907233
57
2.7756817
3.49261149
1.467155
4.98269845
3.078305
3.098005
58
3.6374691
1.7667698
1.773218
4.91166297
1.027662
1.042171
59
0.0532903
2.09543344
0.843303
10.2855119
3.072019
3.105594
60
1.954398
1.715287
0.793207
2.73824568
0.879894
0.887063
61
1.4943676
4.01765403
0.882634
4.87766323
0.8936
0.940814
62
3.1932235
1.71114073
0.89625
4.97132155
1.146807
1.1353
63
0.0532903
4.0526445
2.866731
0.99322503
9.460221
9.479649
64
2.1963506
1.49497801
2.876233
12.8602048
1.353794
1.30921
65
2.5395713
2.56042136
0.962948
10.7058659
5.266034
5.222153
66
1.777885
2.1015945
0.95443
0.92157007
0.999773
1.024108
67
1.8750168
3.31873935
0.950515
2.71722026
3.008141
3.04124
68
1.994689
1.31469745
0.888873
6.57412607
1.003533
0.998415
69
1.8955503
2.95390729
1.708796
2.90320348
0.994754
0.992537
70
1.8414512
2.62001219
2.001997
8.88735161
0.975307
1.003249
71
3.3488586
2.67989525
0.753094
14.8743948
0.982918
0.990547
72
2.7138155
1.56776269
0.822026
6.88096323
0.988096
0.996476
73
3.8698575
3.23182922
3.501343
4.93361807
2.930031
2.962133
74
3.8470712
2.22932302
1.665641
3.02031961
0.953017
0.9606
75
2.8111708
2.11657275
2.486446
4.38248955
0.869143
0.847444
76
1.9400733
2.18113869
0.782514
2.53821174
0.678865
0.673127
77
1.6473314
1.28993452
0.205472
4.89274439
0.723819
0.711026
78
2.1050572
2.55937108
1.032065
2.96058542
2.628607
2.603131
79
1.7176747
1.93797284
2.682008
4.88571006
0.931159
0.959802
80
1.9909898
2.06656014
1.425749
0.960679
0.957032
81
3.2146502
4.65232294
0.85831
0.960257
0.987203
82
2.95907
1.90425807
1.019405
0.959185
0.973435
83
2.7428901
1.55356642
5.146495
0.970956
0.978565
84
0.0378065
1.68721962
0.946677
1.005567
0.996249
85
3.079392
3.44844975
0.895436
0.949156
0.974333
86
4.5020981
1.85254886
0.656942
1.009251
1.014985
87
3.9024432
4.04370763
0.645179
0.996625
0.995208
88
2.8997397
1.98952945
2.13414
0.999142
1.052778
89
3.3251212
3.12231457
2.304694
9.328359
9.311068
90
2.1874106
2.40483192
0.662366
2.960844
2.991622
91
1.9246382
1.74143734
0.450039
8.037046
8.044436
92
2.0318122
2.91798723
1.129225
0.446191
0.384609
93
1.7805613
3.07635647
3.425294
1.429491
1.435924
94
1.9853759
2.44727611
1.175364
0.910507
0.89959
95
2.863035
3.35159435
1.691766
3.09037
3.073034
96
3.1877799
2.52642133
2.061139
0.820848
0.836608
97
5.3795643
2.30624101
0.789433
1.033323
1.020682
98
4.55932
1.86382069
0.644554
0.99304
0.996906
99
2.6410007
2.36713247
0.585822
5.317398
5.347204
100
0.0378065
1.43475183
1.217514
0.571664
0.556586
101
3.0004001
2.16983893
3.425954
6.403354
6.391492
102
3.0257533
1.35224929
0.801975
0.593475
0.616601
103
2.8887875
2.96685978
1.808644
3.112822
3.102034
104
1.7377354
2.5587856
1.258479
0.944764
0.948817
105
2.1610322
2.35054638
1.976514
0.93368
0.932431
106
2.0731809
1.53620335
0.447329
0.943347
0.925902
107
2.0302567
1.89336426
1.0489
3.189666
3.203618
108
2.0573139
2.04989127
2.98365
0.924421
0.930771
109
2.8764
3.15940959
0.912856
0.943382
0.947306
110
2.9346962
1.97520651
0.753454
0.905848
0.895851
111
4.9592495
3.00360571
0.854643
0.937878
0.93322
112
1.9042639
1.65216033
0.905133
0.929599
0.934823
113
0.0532903
2.99472269
5.268046
0.914395
0.914716
114
2.9358604
2.9696346
1.064356
0.868175
0.865078
115
2.08796
3.522561
2.726234
2.75463
2.736351
116
0.0378065
2.17021695
1.402024
0.4497
0.458532
117
2.8200119
1.13882549
1.430055
4.88175
4.877523
118
3.1644216
1.92502833
0.08624
0.847632
0.7741
119
1.1000553
2.33552524
0.533383
3.179227
3.305891
120
0.0378065
2.16282508
0.784668
0.999635
1.002343
121
1.5648289
2.87242212
2.635344
2.986421
2.992172
122
2.0429153
2.08175483
0.756845
0.971743
0.978232
123
1.920074
3.35338172
2.119691
0.987704
0.996188
124
2.0624425
2.49877187
2.672006
0.995507
0.994374
125
1.6385622
2.44468381
1.064622
0.906496
0.920171
126
2.3516614
2.70209182
1.057349
0.953628
0.958107
127
3.023325
2.20520443
1.716475
0.917255
0.918416
128
3.0386653
1.7528927
2.093446
0.841593
0.84152
129
4.82131
0.86268695
0.62255
0.689189
0.687297
130
3.2698152
1.74258637
0.839153
0.741565
0.74184
131
0.0858922
4.14142181
0.619628
4.646821
4.640992
132
2.0613079
2.79021581
0.951964
0.967305
0.968871
133
4.5317917
3.67614862
5.745348
0.962225
0.958825
134
3.3586502
2.04823356
1.012427
0.960894
0.960314
135
3.0385163
3.39496613
0.814653
0.959172
0.958669
136
1.7362652
1.21114837
0.349122
0.961976
0.960929
137
1.8660618
4.83712281
1.36382
0.959798
0.954147
138
2.1012206
2.31272424
1.883338
0.962403
0.958655
139
1.5916468
2.2134092
1.99204
0.959899
0.950886
140
2.4082921
1.93488583
1.880721
0.960048
0.957164
141
3.00735
3.01899489
1.533148
0.94753
0.944815
142
3.0673785
1.88364441
0.989974
0.913535
0.912069
143
4.9352169
3.388834
4.223902
0.868366
0.866665
144
3.047188
1.50863368
0.557933
0.771248
0.77092
145
2.8391557
3.65383834
0.838395
0.625116
0.624953
146
2.2018168
0.93531504
1.78453
0.776709
0.782272
147
2.1111701
4.07068582
1.706629
0.882862
0.889185
148
1.9872768
0.96683748
2.323612
0.939862
0.941413
149
2.0656612
2.81627838
1.486917
0.966876
0.963163
150
1.9417109
1.74563648
1.076442
0.970821
0.977529
151
2.7912488
2.085939
5.905075
2.932218
2.938957
152
1.9324392
2.65859237
0.962279
1.013816
1.00252
153
3.85670546
0.855204
0.487223
0.458218
154
2.05006881
1.653053
155
1.85354628
1.529038
156
3.08429693
2.539171
157
4.94706635
1.473741
158
2.27534395
1.131953
159
2.09944207
0.954754
160
2.38394995
161
2.58365725
162
2.61673865
163
2.83734887
164
1.47022406
165
3.25600168
166
2.00050605
167
3.14456799
168
2.42375995
169
1.48818758
170
2.73687482
171
3.50611056
172
2.39342344
173
2.36413223
174
2.01771652
175
1.93419761
176
2.05363658
177
2.25656255
178
3.4781908
179
2.26728281
180
0.73891319
181
4.36526366
182
1.49947139
183
1.87240249
184
3.00696302
185
2.10520017
For all designs, the first layer is a high-index layer.
Table 10
Names and Addresses of Contributors of NBP Designs
Name
Address
E-Mail Address
Jennifer D. T. Kruschwitz
JK Consulting, 47 Rossiter Road, Rochester, N.Y. 14620